Why Most Hostile People Training is Complete Rubbish (And What Actually Works)

The bloke in accounts receivable who slams his phone down every time someone questions an invoice. The woman in procurement who treats every supplier meeting like a military interrogation. That manager who somehow makes "Good morning" sound like a personal insult.

We've all worked with them. Hostile people who turn every interaction into a battlefield, leaving colleagues walking on eggshells and productivity tanking faster than a Perth property market in winter. And what does corporate Australia do about it? Roll out another generic "difficult people" workshop that teaches everyone to smile more and use "I" statements.

Absolute codswallop.

After 18 years of running businesses and training teams across Melbourne, Brisbane, and Adelaide, I can tell you that 87% of workplace hostility training programs are about as effective as a chocolate teapot. They're designed by people who've never had to deal with Barry from logistics having a meltdown because someone moved his stapler three centimetres to the left.

The Problem with Feel-Good Training

Most hostile people training falls into the same tired traps. It assumes everyone's reasonable underneath it all. It focuses on "understanding" the hostile person's perspective. It suggests you can neutralise aggression with active listening and empathy.

Here's the uncomfortable truth: some people are just arseholes. Not because they had a bad childhood or feel unheard at work. They're hostile because it gets them what they want. Because people avoid them. Because conflict makes them feel powerful.

I learned this the hard way in 2019 when I was consulting for a major mining company in Kalgoorlie. They'd spent $40,000 on a three-day "Dealing with Difficult People" program for their entire management team. Beautiful PowerPoint slides, role-playing exercises, the works. Six months later, their star engineer - let's call him Dave - was still verbally abusing junior staff and throwing tools when projects ran behind schedule.

The training had taught everyone how to "validate Dave's feelings" and "find common ground." Meanwhile, Dave had figured out that his hostility was now met with gentle nodding and concerned listening. He'd basically been rewarded for being a nightmare.

What Actually Works: The Melbourne Method

Forget everything you think you know about handling hostile people. Real-world hostile people training isn't about understanding - it's about boundaries, consequences, and strategic disengagement.

Boundary Setting That Sticks

The first rule of dealing with hostile people: you don't owe them your emotional labour. Full stop. When someone's being hostile, you don't need to fix them, understand them, or make them feel better. You need to protect yourself and get the job done.

I teach what I call the "Traffic Light System." Green light conversations are normal professional interactions. Yellow light means you're dealing with someone who's frustrated but still functioning rationally. Red light? That's when someone's crossed into hostile territory - raised voice, personal attacks, unreasonable demands, or intimidation tactics.

Here's where most training gets it wrong. They try to turn red lights into green lights through magical communication techniques. Wrong approach entirely. When someone hits red light behaviour, your job isn't to fix them. It's to disengage safely and set consequences.

The Power of Strategic Disengagement

This one drives HR departments mental, but it works. When someone becomes hostile, you have permission to stop the conversation. Not tomorrow. Not after you've tried three de-escalation techniques. Right now.

"I can see this conversation isn't productive right now. Let's continue this via email." Then you leave. Or hang up. Or end the Zoom call.

I've had trainees worry this seems rude. You know what's rude? Yelling at colleagues. Making people feel unsafe at work. Disrupting everyone else's day with your emotional outbursts.

Strategic disengagement does two things: it protects you from absorbing someone else's toxicity, and it removes the audience that hostile people crave. Most workplace hostility is performance art. Take away the audience, and it loses its power.

The Documentation Game-Changer

Here's something they don't teach in those expensive corporate workshops: document everything. Not just the big incidents - document the patterns.

Every time someone's hostile, make a note. Date, time, witnesses, what triggered it, how it affected the work environment. After three weeks, you'll see patterns that would make a psychologist weep. Tuesday afternoons after client calls. First thing Monday morning. Whenever certain colleagues are in the room.

This isn't about building a case to fire someone (though it might end up there). It's about understanding the system that enables hostility. Because here's another uncomfortable truth: hostile people don't exist in isolation. They're usually enabled by weak management, unclear consequences, or organisational cultures that confuse aggression with passion.

Related Articles:

• Tag Group Posts
• Label Team Insights

Why Australian Workplaces Get This Wrong

We've got this weird cultural thing where we confuse directness with hostility and politeness with effectiveness. I've seen Melbourne businesses tolerate absolute monsters because they "get results" or "tell it like it is." Meanwhile, they'll send gentle, constructive feedback-givers to communication training.

It's arse-backwards.

Real hostile people training teaches you to recognise the difference between someone having a bad day and someone who uses aggression as a management tool. It gives you permission to refuse to be someone's emotional punching bag. And it acknowledges that sometimes, the solution isn't training - it's termination.

The Stress Management Connection

One thing I've noticed after years in this game: organisations that struggle with hostile people almost always have systemic stress management issues. When everyone's running on empty, when deadlines are impossible, when resources are stretched thinner than vegemite on toast, hostility becomes a survival mechanism.

You can train people how to handle hostile colleagues until you're blue in the face. But if you don't address the underlying stressors that create hostile environments, you're just putting band-aids on bullet wounds.

I worked with a Sydney tech startup where the CEO prided himself on "high-performance culture." What he'd actually created was a pressure cooker where everyone was either hostile or headed for burnout. No amount of "difficult conversations" training was going to fix that. They needed to look at their workload, their expectations, and their definition of success.

The Bottom Line

Hostile people training that works isn't about making nice with difficult personalities. It's about setting boundaries, protecting your mental health, and creating consequences for unacceptable behaviour. It's about recognising that some people choose hostility as a strategy, and your job isn't to cure them - it's to protect yourself and your team.

Most importantly, it's about giving yourself permission to refuse to be treated badly. Even at work. Even by colleagues. Even by clients or customers who "pay the bills."

Because here's what 18 years in business has taught me: the cost of tolerating hostile people - in turnover, productivity, and workplace culture - is always higher than the cost of addressing the problem head-on.

And if that makes me sound hostile? Well, maybe it's time your organisation learned the difference between setting boundaries and being difficult.