Why Growth Mindset Training is Actually Making Your Employees Weaker (And What You Should Do Instead)

Related Articles:

• Brand Local Blog
• Statement Coach Resources

Here's the thing nobody wants to admit about growth mindset training: most of it's absolute rubbish.

I've been running workplace development programs across Australia for the past 18 years, and I can't tell you how many boardrooms I've walked into where some well-meaning HR director starts rattling off about "embracing failure" and "the power of yet." Meanwhile, their teams are burning out left, right, and centre because they've been told that struggling means they're not trying hard enough.

Don't get me wrong - I'm not against the concept entirely. Carol Dweck's original research was solid. But somewhere between Stanford University and your average corporate training room in Melbourne, something got lost in translation.

The Real Problem with Traditional Growth Mindset Training

Most programs I see are teaching people to be perpetually dissatisfied with their current performance. That's not growth - that's anxiety with a motivational poster slapped on top.

I was working with a logistics company in Brisbane last year where they'd implemented one of those "embrace the challenge" programs. Six months later, their staff turnover had increased by 34%. Why? Because telling someone who's already working 50-hour weeks that they need to "lean into discomfort" isn't inspiring - it's bloody exhausting.

The classic growth mindset approach tells people that talent is meaningless and effort is everything. Bollocks. Some people are naturally better at certain things, and pretending otherwise is doing everyone a disservice. I've seen brilliant analytical minds forced into relationship-building roles because "anyone can develop people skills with enough effort."

Wrong.

What Actually Works: Strategic Growth Mindset

Here's what I've learned works better: targeted growth mindset training that acknowledges natural strengths while strategically developing specific areas.

Instead of blanket "you can do anything" messaging, effective programs help people identify where growth actually matters for their role and career trajectory. Not everything needs to be developed. Some weaknesses are perfectly fine to manage rather than eliminate.

I remember working with Woolworths' regional management team in 2019 (brilliant people, by the way - really understood the importance of practical development). We focused on three specific growth areas per person rather than trying to develop everything. The results spoke for themselves - 89% of participants reported feeling more confident about their development goals, and productivity metrics improved across the board.

The Three Pillars That Actually Matter

1. Selective Struggle Not all challenges are worth embracing. Teach your people to choose their battles. A finance manager doesn't need to develop public speaking skills to the same level as someone in sales. Stop wasting time and energy on everything.

2. Evidence-Based Confidence
Instead of feel-good platitudes, show people concrete evidence of their progress. Track specific metrics, celebrate measurable improvements, and be honest about what's working and what isn't.

The problem with most growth mindset training is it's too bloody nice. People need honest feedback, not constant encouragement. I've never met a high performer who got there through participation trophies.

3. Strategic Failure This might sound counterintuitive, but plan your failures. Identify low-stakes situations where people can practice new skills without major consequences. Most workplaces either avoid failure entirely or throw people in the deep end. Neither approach works.

Where Most Companies Get It Wrong

The biggest mistake I see is treating growth mindset as a one-size-fits-all solution. Your IT team needs different development approaches than your sales team. Your Gen Z employees have different motivations than your baby boomers.

Stop running generic workshops and start designing targeted interventions.

I was chatting with a CEO from Perth recently who told me they'd spent $40,000 on growth mindset training and saw zero measurable improvement. When I looked at their program, they'd basically run the same session for everyone from graduate engineers to senior executives. Of course it didn't work.

The Australian Context Nobody Talks About

Here's something the American-imported training programs miss: Australians are naturally skeptical of overly positive messaging. We can smell BS from a kilometre away.

Effective growth mindset training in Australia needs to acknowledge this. Don't try to turn your workforce into relentlessly optimistic self-improvers. Work with the cultural tendency toward pragmatism and straight talk.

I've found that framing development as problem-solving rather than personal transformation gets much better buy-in. Australians love solving problems - we're just not into the touchy-feely stuff.

What to Do Tomorrow

If you're serious about implementing growth mindset principles that actually work, start here:

Audit your current training. How much time are you spending on generic motivation versus specific skill development? If it's more than 20% motivation, you're probably wasting money.

Survey your teams about their development goals. Not what they think they should want to develop, but what they actually need to grow in their current roles. The answers might surprise you.

Most importantly, stop treating growth mindset as a cure-all for performance issues. Sometimes poor performance is about systems, processes, or simply having the wrong person in the wrong role. No amount of mindset training will fix a fundamental mismatch.

The companies that get this right - like Telstra's customer service division and several mining companies I've worked with in Western Australia - focus on practical skill development with a growth orientation, not philosophical discussions about the nature of ability.

They track results, adjust approaches based on evidence, and aren't afraid to admit when something isn't working.

That's real growth mindset in action.

The Bottom Line

Growth mindset training can be powerful, but only when it's strategic, specific, and honest about limitations. Stop trying to convince everyone they can be anything and start helping them become excellent at what matters most.

Your employees will thank you for it. More importantly, your bottom line will too.

---

Looking for stress management training that actually works? Our approach focuses on practical strategies rather than feel-good theory.